Kylie Sheehan was selected as one of eight players on the prestigious United State Polo Association's Team USPA for 2013 and the inaugural US collegiate team. 

At GFS, Kylie was an all-star player and co-captain of the 2009 national championship team, the same year the Polo Training Foundation named her Interscholastic Interscholastic Player of the Year. She played at the University of Virginia where she earned a B.A. in Foreign Affairs with a concentration in Latin America and the Middle East. In addition to four years on the dean's list, she was a four-year starter for UVA's women's team and captain for three years. She garnered numerous all-star awards and was integral in the team's 2012 national intercollegiate championship. Kylie also played with the UVA Polo Club and served as president her senior year.

Kylie traveled in summer 2012 to Southeast Asia to play in the Royal Malaysian Polo Association Ladies Championships. In 2016, Kylie played in the Pink Polo Breast Cancer Benefit match in Nigeria as a member of Team USPA.